Swapping the promo every month: insert mat or reprint?
Example thread · fictional members and dates What does this mean?
- This topic has 16 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 7 months, 1 week ago by
GiftShop_Asheville.
- AuthorPosts
- April 7, 2026 at 7:45 am #5619
CStore_Owner_Ohio
ParticipantWe change the featured deal every month at both stores. Coffee and a breakfast sandwich in winter, fountain drinks in summer, whatever the distributor is pushing that month. The deal does move product when people see it. The problem is that a taped sign gets wet, torn and half covered by the receipt printer. Right now the deal lives on a paper sign taped to the register, and it looks bad by day three.
As I see it, there are two options: a mat with a slot for a paper insert, or a new printed mat every month. Which one makes sense at two stores with four registers?
April 7, 2026 at 9:00 am #5620GiftShop_Asheville
ParticipantInsert mat, without a doubt, at your scale. A new printed mat every month means a print run every month for four registers, plus storing or throwing out the old ones. With an insert you print a sheet, slide it in, done.
I do it for seasonal events. Ten minutes at the start of the month. I keep the insert files in one folder named by month, so next year’s spring sheet is last year’s with new dates. The first year takes some work. After that it’s mostly copy and paste.
April 7, 2026 at 10:15 am #5621TradeMktg_Atlanta
ParticipantI’ll put in a word for the insert too, from the brand side and for a different reason. When we run a promotion in a store, we often supply the insert sheet ourselves, already designed. A store with an insert mat can take our promotion the same week. A store with a printed mat can’t.
So an insert mat also makes you easier to work with for the brands that fund promotions.
April 7, 2026 at 11:30 am #5622CStore_Owner_Ohio
ParticipantThe distributor rep did offer printed sheets once. I had nowhere to put them, so they went in a drawer. They’re probably still there, under the spare receipt rolls.
April 7, 2026 at 1:00 pm #5623GiftShop_Asheville
ParticipantWatch the paper quality with inserts. Regular copy paper curls under the cover after a few weeks of hot coffee cups and sun through the window. Heavier paper or card stock stays flat. And print with a margin, since the edges of the pocket hide a little of the sheet. Keep the price and the item name in the middle of the page. If anything gets cut off, it should be a bit of background color, not the deal.
April 7, 2026 at 2:20 pm #5624TradeMktg_Atlanta
ParticipantAnd glare. A glossy insert under a clear cover under store lights can be hard to read from where the customer stands. Matte paper reads better. Check it at the time of day your store is busiest, with the real lights on. A sheet that looks fine in the back office can be a white rectangle at the register.
April 7, 2026 at 4:00 pm #5625CStore_Owner_Ohio
ParticipantIs there ever a case for printing a new mat each time?
April 8, 2026 at 8:30 am #5626TradeMktg_Atlanta
ParticipantYes, when the promotion runs long and looks matter more than flexibility. Our big summer program runs three months, and for that we use fully printed mats in our top stores. Edge-to-edge color, no pocket line, and it looks like a finished piece. For a monthly deal, the insert wins.
A hybrid also works: a printed mat with your logo and colors around the edge and an insert pocket in the middle for the monthly deal. You get the look and the flexibility.
April 8, 2026 at 9:45 am #5627GiftShop_Asheville
ParticipantThat hybrid is what I’d want if I did it again. The plain frame around my insert looks a bit generic next to everything else in the shop.
April 8, 2026 at 12:15 pm #5628CounterMats Team
ModeratorFor a deal that changes every month, an insert mat lets you change the message with a printed sheet instead of a new mat, and a printed frame around the insert keeps your branding on the counter. That’s the hybrid TradeMktg_Atlanta describes.
Our Interchangeable Counter mat is the custom printed version with an insert, so the frame can carry your logo and colors: https://countermats.com/product/interchangeable-counter-mats/
For a stock option, the Stock Interchangeable mat comes in 10.5 x 13 in, which holds an 8.5 x 11 insert, and 13 x 19 in, which holds an 11 x 17 insert. We also make it in a custom size. Current prices are on the product page: https://countermats.com/product/stock-interchangeable/
Stock mats ship the same business day on orders placed by 1 pm ET. Printed mats ship 5 business days after proof approval, for orders up to 2,500 mats, and every printed order gets a free digital proof within 1 business day. The minimum order is 50 mats.
CounterMats Team · Contact Us
April 8, 2026 at 2:40 pm #5629CStore_Owner_Ohio
ParticipantFifty covers both stores many times over. I’d put the extras at the coffee station and the lottery counter, which gives me two more spots for the monthly deal.
April 8, 2026 at 3:55 pm #5630GiftShop_Asheville
ParticipantSpares are handy with inserts, too. Set up next month’s insert in a spare mat ahead of time, then swap the whole mat on the first of the month. It takes seconds at a busy register.
Put the swap on the opening checklist for the first of the month with a name next to it. At my shop, the new insert sat on the back table for a week once because everyone thought someone else had done it.
April 9, 2026 at 8:20 am #5631TradeMktg_Atlanta
ParticipantTell your distributor rep you have insert mats now, and send them the insert size. You’ll be surprised how often a free printed sheet shows up after that.
April 9, 2026 at 9:35 am #5632CStore_Owner_Ohio
ParticipantThe free sheet part I like. What size do reps usually send?
April 9, 2026 at 10:50 am #5633TradeMktg_Atlanta
ParticipantLetter size is the most common for counter pieces, because every store can print a replacement on its own printer. Tabloid shows up for bigger displays. Ask before they print, since a sheet that doesn’t fit the pocket ends up taped to the register again. And ask how long the promotion runs, so the sheet doesn’t sit there showing last month’s price.
April 9, 2026 at 1:10 pm #5634CStore_Owner_Ohio
ParticipantDecision made. Insert mats with our logo printed around the pocket, letter-size inserts, card stock, matte. The first insert goes in for May. The taped sign goes in the trash.
April 9, 2026 at 2:30 pm #5635GiftShop_Asheville
ParticipantGood choice. Take a photo of each month’s insert on the counter, too. After a year you’ll have a record of which deals people actually asked about, and it makes next year’s planning much faster.
- AuthorPosts
- Log in or create an account to post. Anyone can read.