...

What should I check on a proof before I approve it?

Example thread · fictional members and dates What does this mean?

Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #5315

    We’re about to get the proof for a new register mat across all 38 shops. Last rollout, a phone number went out with one wrong digit. Nobody caught it on the proof, and we lived with that mat for a year.

    What do people actually check on a proof, and in what order? I want a routine, not a feeling.

    #5316
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    Here’s my order, and the order matters, because people stop checking once they find the first mistake.

    • Text: read every word out loud, then read it backward word by word for typos
    • Numbers: call the phone number, type the web address into a browser, scan any QR code
    • Logo: the right version, the right colors, nothing stretched
    • Edges: nothing important close to the trim line
    • Size and orientation: the right dimensions, and the text facing the customer
    • Version: the proof matches the final file, not last week’s draft
    #5317
    CreditUnion_Ops_PA
    Participant

    Add a compliance step if anything on the mat is regulated. At the credit union, any rate or product claim needs approved wording, and our compliance team reviews the proof itself, not the draft we sent. The draft and the proof can differ when a file gets resaved.

    Get the sign-off in writing, with a name and a date. When questions come up later, that email is the only thing that counts.

    We also check the small print at the bottom of the proof, like the equal housing logo or the insurance line. Those are the first things a designer shrinks to make room, and the first things an examiner notices.

    #5318
    BikeShop_Boise
    Participant

    New shop owner here, about to do my first mat. What does “close to the trim line” mean? How close is too close?

    #5319
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    The printer cuts the mat from a bigger sheet, and the cut can drift a little. So there are two zones. Bleed is extra background that runs past the cut so you don’t get a white sliver at the edge. The safe zone is a margin inside the cut where nothing important goes.

    A common rule is to keep text and logos at least half an inch inside the edge. On a mat, add more at the front edge, because hands and elbows rest there all day.

    #5320

    The version check would have saved us last time. The proof looked right, but it was built from the file before legal changed one line. Now the file name carries a version number, and the proof email has to name it. If a proof doesn’t say which version it was built from, we send it back before anyone reads a word.

    #5321
    BikeShop_Boise
    Participant

    How do I judge color? My logo is a specific green, and on my laptop the proof looks a little blue.

    #5322
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    A screen is lit from behind, and a mat isn’t. A digital proof shows layout, text and placement well. It shows color only roughly. If your green matters, give the printer a color reference from a printed swatch book, not a screen value, and ask how they match it.

    Never approve color from a phone screen. Phone brightness changes everything.

    If color is critical, ask whether a physical proof is possible and what it adds to the schedule. For most small-shop logos, a close match is fine, and the digital proof is enough to check everything else.

    #5323
    CounterMats Team
    Moderator

    Designer_PDX’s order of checks matches ours almost line for line, and CreditUnion_Ops_PA’s written sign-off is a habit worth copying.

    Every printed order gets a free digital proof within 1 business day. Our proof page explains what a proof checks beyond the obvious, why a digital proof cannot catch everything (screen color is one of those limits), what to check when the proof arrives and why it pays to approve quickly once it’s right.

    Printed mats ship 5 business days after proof approval, so the approval date sets the ship date. If you want changes, send all of them in one reply. The 5 business days count from the approved proof, so each extra round moves the ship date.

    What to check on your proof: https://countermats.com/custom-counter-mat-proof/

    CounterMats Team · Contact Us

    #5324
    CreditUnion_Ops_PA
    Participant

    Sending all changes in one reply is harder than it sounds when four people review. We collect comments in one shared document first, and one person sends them. Nobody emails the printer directly.

    #5325

    Same here now. And if a design has store-specific parts, like a phone number per store, every variant gets its own check. We had one shared layout with 38 phone numbers. Checking the layout once isn’t checking the numbers.

    For those, we print a list of every variant with the store number and phone number side by side and tick each one off against the proof. It’s boring, and it’s the only way we’ve found that works.

    #5326
    BikeShop_Boise
    Participant

    My mat was going to say “Grand opening June 14”. Is it a mistake to print a date?

    #5327
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    Usually, yes. A date makes the mat useless the day after. Opening dates also move, and then you have a counter full of wrong information. Print what stays true: the name, what you do, the web address. Put the date on a sign you can throw away, or on a window cling.

    Same rule for prices. Anything that changes belongs somewhere cheaper to replace.

    #5328
    BikeShop_Boise
    Participant

    Taking the date off. That would have been me, exactly. The opening already moved once, from May to June when the permit took longer, and I’d have a stack of mats with the wrong month on them.

    #5329

    Our routine from now on, for anyone who wants it. Two people check the proof separately. One reads every word out loud. One calls every phone number and types every web address. The person who wrote the text is never the only checker. Compliance signs off on the proof, not the draft. One person sends one reply with every change.

    #5330
    CreditUnion_Ops_PA
    Participant

    Add a line for who has final say. When two reviewers disagree on the proof, someone has to decide that day, or the schedule slips while they debate. For us that’s the branch operations lead, and compliance can only veto, not redesign.

Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)
  • Log in or create an account to post. Anyone can read.

Log in

Forgot your password?

Join the Counter Mat Forum

Everyone sees this. A role works well instead of your name, for example CStore_Owner_Ohio.

Members, discussions and dates in threads marked Example thread are fictional. CounterMats wrote them to explain common counter mat questions in plain language.

Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.