...

Will our brand red print the same across 30 stores?

Example thread · fictional members and dates What does this mean?

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #5702

    We’re rolling out new register mats to 30 of our 38 sandwich shops this fall. The other 8 are mid-remodel and get theirs in spring.

    Our brand red is the whole identity. Last time we did printed signage, store 11’s red came out closer to orange and the franchisee sent me a photo every week until we reprinted. How do I make sure the red on mat 1 matches mat 30, and the spring batch matches the fall one?

    The mats sit right next to the menu board and the cups, which are printed by different vendors on different materials. Customers won’t notice if two mats are a hair apart. Franchisees will, and so will our brand team, because they walk stores with the brand book open.

    #5703
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    Start with the file, because that’s where most color drift begins. Does your brand guide give the red as a Pantone number, a CMYK build, or both?

    Screens show color in RGB, presses print in CMYK or with spot inks, and a red that looks perfect on a monitor can shift a lot in print. If the printer gets an RGB logo from a website, they convert it, and every conversion is a guess.

    #5704

    The guide has a Pantone number and a CMYK build. I’m not sure anyone has sent the printer anything but a PNG, though.

    #5705
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    Then that’s fix number one. Send a vector file, AI or PDF, with the red defined as the CMYK build from your guide, and the Pantone number written in the notes. Ask the printer which one they print to on mats. Some print processes match a Pantone target by mixing CMYK, some can’t hit certain reds at all, and you want to hear that before the proof, not after.

    #5706
    PromoBuyer_Chicago
    Participant

    One run, one file, one material. That’s the buying side of it. Store 11’s orange almost always comes from one of those three changing. A second printer, a reprint from an old file, or a different material.

    Material matters more than people expect. The same red prints differently on a fabric top than on a smooth vinyl surface. If the fall batch and the spring batch use different materials, they won’t match no matter how good the file is.

    #5707

    So the spring batch is the real risk. Eight stores, six months later.

    #5708
    PromoBuyer_Chicago
    Participant

    It is. Two ways around it. Print all 38 in the fall run and hold the 8 until the remodels finish. Or keep the exact file, the material spec and a reference mat from the fall run, and send all three with the spring job.

    Printing everything at once costs storage space. Printing later costs a matching risk. For a brand color that’s the whole identity, I’d print once.

    #5709
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    Agree on printing once if you can. And keep a reference mat in your office, out of the sun, in its sleeve. That mat becomes the standard. When a franchisee says the red looks off, you compare their mat to the reference under the same light, not to a photo on a phone.

    Phones lie about red worse than any other color.

    #5710

    That would have saved me six weeks of photos from store 11. Their lighting is warm LED. Everything in that store looks orange, including the sandwiches.

    Which raises a question for Designer_PDX. If the stores have different lighting, is there any point chasing a perfect match? Or do I just accept that store 11 will always look a little warmer?

    #5711
    CounterMats Team
    Moderator

    Store lighting comes up in a lot of rollouts, and the advice in this thread lines up with ours.

    Our page on franchise rollouts covers why mats drift out of spec, why it pays to order the whole rollout at once even if it ships in waves, deciding what franchisees can change and keeping the file that produced the mats: https://countermats.com/franchise-counter-mats-rollout/

    On our side, every printed order gets a free digital proof within 1 business day. A screen shows layout and placement well, so check color against your guide’s values and your reference piece, not the monitor alone. Printed orders ship 5 business days after proof approval, on orders up to 2,500 mats. We charge no setup fees, so a later run from the same file carries no extra setup charge.

    CounterMats Team · Contact Us

    #5712

    Order everything, ship in waves. That’s the part I didn’t know was an option.

    Designer_PDX, still curious about the lighting question. Our brand team will ask.

    #5713
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    Chase the match in the print, accept the lighting. Your job is making sure every mat leaves the press the same. What the store’s bulbs do to it afterward is a store standard, not a print problem. If the brand team cares, the fix is a lighting spec for the stores, and that’s a much bigger project than mats.

    #5714
    PromoBuyer_Chicago
    Participant

    Get it written into the quote either way. Quantity, ship dates per wave, the material, and the file name. If the spring wave happens on a different date than planned, nobody has to remember what was agreed.

    #5715
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    Last file tip. Name the master file with the date and the color build in it, something like “register-mat-master-2026-fall-red-CMYK.pdf”, and lock it. Don’t let anyone open it, tweak a headline and save over it. When the next rollout comes, start from a copy.

    And keep the red away from big flat areas next to a lot of white if you can. Large solid red fields show any variation more than a red logo on a pattern does.

    #5716

    Pulling this together for our marketing folder:

    • Vector file with the CMYK build from the guide and the Pantone number in the notes
    • Ask the printer which one they print to on mats
    • One run, one file, one material, all 38 stores
    • Hold the remodel stores’ mats until they open
    • Keep a reference mat in a sleeve, out of the sun
    • Compare complaints against the reference in the same light
    • Master file named, dated and locked
    #5717
    Designer_PDX
    Participant

    Good list. I’d also send the franchisees a photo of the reference mat taken in neutral light with the install note, so they know what “right” looks like before they start comparing.

    #5718

    Doing that. And store 11 gets new bulbs before the mats go in.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
  • Log in or create an account to post. Anyone can read.

Log in

Forgot your password?

Join the Counter Mat Forum

Everyone sees this. A role works well instead of your name, for example CStore_Owner_Ohio.

Members, discussions and dates in threads marked Example thread are fictional. CounterMats wrote them to explain common counter mat questions in plain language.

Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.